Hall of Pretty Darn Goodhallofpdg.com
Start here

What is this place?

Think of every name you’ve argued for at a bar, in a group chat, or over a family dinner — “How is they not in the Hall of Fame?” This Hall exists for exactly those arguments.

“Not the greatest of all time. Just… pretty darn good for a very long time, and loved for it.”

We celebrate the rock bands who sold millions without a Rock Hall call, the character actors who stole every scene, the .300 hitters, the 30-goal scorers, the quarterbacks who won you Sundays — the careers that made being a fan fun.

SN
Run by Scott Norman — “the Commissioner”

Scott keeps the roster, posts the matchups, counts every vote (nicknames and shorthand count too), and writes up the results. It’s a one-man commission with a very large, very opinionated electorate: you.

The Hall of Pretty Darn Good logo — a smiling otter in a round badge reading Hall of Pretty Darn Good, hallofpdg.com

What you’ll find here

  • A real roster, 300+ deep — music, film & TV, baseball, football, basketball, hockey, and gloriously miscellaneous.
  • Only positive debates. We argue for people here. No “worst ever” lists, no tearing anyone down.

New here? Start by following on Facebook — that’s where the ballot lives. This site is the Hall’s front door and trophy case.

★ The House Rule ★

Only positive debates.

We argue for people here.

That’s the whole deal, and it’s non-negotiable. Every argument in this Hall is a case for somebody — why they mattered, why you loved them, why they deserve the plaque. If a name isn’t your favorite, make the case for yours instead.

✕  No “worst ever” lists ✕  No tearing anyone down ✓  Just make the case for your favorite

Argue for somebody — it’s more fun anyway.

Eligibility

Who gets in — and who can’t

The Hall has one big idea: if the big halls already took care of you, you don’t need us. We’re here for everyone they missed.

✓ Eligible — pretty darn good

  • Beloved, accomplished, and somehow still on the outside of the major halls
  • Long, excellent careers — stars, cult heroes, and scene-stealers alike
  • Regional or state Hall of Famers are eligible — those don’t disqualify anyone (for example, Survivor’s Illinois Rock & Roll Hall of Fame induction didn’t bar them here)
  • Bands, solo artists, actors, athletes, broadcasters, and delightful oddballs like the San Diego Chicken

✕ Not eligible — already honored

  • Already in a major / national Hall of Fame for their field
  • Knighted (sorry, Sirs and Dames — you’ve got a palace already)
  • Oscar winners
  • Kennedy Center Honors recipients
  • AFI Lifetime Achievement Award winners

That’s not a knock — it’s the whole point. Those folks went home to a bigger hall. We keep the door open for the rest.

🏆 Good to knowSometimes our inductees do get called up to the real thing later. We don’t remove them — we celebrate them in a special category: “They went home.” See below.

The wings of the Hall

🎸 Music — 40+ 🎬 Actors & Entertainers — 65+ ⚾ Baseball — 42 🏈 Football — 28 🏀 Basketball — 39 🏒 Hockey — 36 ✨ Mixed & Miscellaneous — the best wing

♥ Tap the heart on any wing to like that category. Tap again to unlike — your likes are saved in this browser.

Inside the Hall

A taste of the plaques on the wall

This is a sampler — the full roster runs past 300 names. Search for a favorite, filter by wing, and tap any name to open that inductee’s own page. If they’re not here yet, that’s what the Monday vote is for.

Inductee sampler Showing all
♥ Like a categoryShow some love for your favorite wing — tap again to unlike.
Don’t see your favorite? They might be on the nominee list — or waiting for you to suggest them.Browse all inductees A–Z →Suggest a nominee → hallofpdg@gmail.com
Special category

They went home 🏠

When we started this, we knew sooner or later some of our inductees would be inducted into a real Hall of Fame. We don’t remove them — stealing a line from Men in Black about Elvis: “He didn’t die; he went home.” That’s why this section is called They Went Home.

Inducted here first, then called up to their sport’s or music’s real Hall of Fame. We couldn’t be prouder — it proves the fans were right all along.

Pat Benatar → Rock Hall ’22Foreigner → Rock Hall ’24Ozzy Osbourne → Rock Hall ’24Judas Priest → Rock Hall ’22Jeremy Roenick → Hockey HOF ’24Steve McMichael → Pro Football HOF ’24Sterling Sharpe → Pro Football HOF ’25Dave Parker → Baseball HOF ’25Dick Allen → Baseball HOF ’25Michael Cooper → Basketball HOF ’24

Currently nominated — a peek

A few names waiting for their Monday. The full nominee list runs long — these are just near the top of the Commissioner’s desk:

Joe CarterDwight GoodenNomar GarciaparraAndrew LuckTiki BarberMuggsy BoguesCarrie FisherEdward James OlmosYaphet KottoDevoTwisted SisterShane Doan

Follow to vote for them →

Join the electorate

Your favorite deserves a plaque. Come vote them in.

The Hall lives on Facebook and Instagram. Follow along for the Monday matchup, the Friday results, and the daily noon spotlight — and bring a name with you. The best nominations always come from a fan who just can’t believe they’re not in yet.

— Scott “the Commissioner” Norman